The Warrant Clause in the Digital Age
What's at Stake
The information generated by today’s digital devices and online services reveals private matters far beyond what one could learn from physical analogs. In a series of legal filings and a white paper, available below, the ACLU has argued that to keep apace with technological developments and adequately protect our privacy, the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement must be interpreted robustly. Seizures and searches of digital data must be cabined to probable cause, limited to specific categories of information relevant to the investigation, and closely overseen by a neutral magistrate.
Summary
We have a right to strong privacy protections when police seek, obtain, and execute search warrants for digital information, especially because what we store on on our phones, on other digital devices, and in online accounts is so comprehensive and revealing. The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is the primary source of protection for this right, but courts' interpretations of what the Fourth Amendment requires for digital-age warrants to be constitutional have sometimes fallen short. Just as with analog "papers" and "effects," warrants seeking access to our digital records must prevent against the reviled "general searches" that motivated the Fourth Amendment's framing. If anything, the sensitive and intermingled nature of digitally stored information calls for a more protective reading of the warrant requirement, not a relaxed one. The affordances of modern technology must not be allowed to give police license to rummage indiscriminately through our private data for any cause (or no cause at all) and without judicial oversight. Instead, modern day warrants should provide robust protection against overbroad access to our digital information. Firmly established case law, Fourth Amendment first principles, and the practical realities of forensic searches all support this result, and a growing number of courts have recognized that warrants can adequately protect our in privacy interests in digitally stored information without hindering law enforcement from conducting legitimate investigations.
This paper identifies features of electronically stored data that pose novel problems for our Fourth Amendment rights, and highlights how current search-warrant practice falls short. Drawing on amicus briefs the ACLU has filed in state and federal courts across the country, the paper then sets forth legal arguments in support of robust rules for obtaining and executing warrants in the digital age. Defense attorneys, magistrates, and prosecutors seeking to protect privacy while permitting legitimate investigations can benefit from this paper, as well as the briefing and opinions included in the paper appendices.
For assistance with a case involving these issues, feel free to contact the author, Jennifer Stisa Granick, Surveillance & Cybersecurity Counsel with the ACLU's Speech, Privacy, & Technology Project.
Legal Documents
-
ACLU Paper: Warrants in the Digital Age -
- Making Warrants Great Again: Avoiding General Searches in the Execution of Warrants for Electronic Data
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsMaking Warrants Great Again: Avoiding General Searches in the Execution of Warrants for Electronic Data
-
Appendix Materials -
- Appendix
- Supplemental Appendix
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsSupplemental Appendix -
ACLU Amicus Briefs (& Related Opinions) on Digital-Age Warrants -
- State v. Hughes (Mich.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. Hughes (Mich.), Michigan Supreme Court Opinion
- People v. McCavitt (Ill.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- People v. McCavitt (Ill.), Illinois Supreme Court Opinion
- State v. Burch (Wisc.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. Burch (Wisc.), Wisconsin Supreme Court Opinion
- In re Search Warrant to Google (Cal. Super. Ct.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- In re Search Warrant to Google (Cal. Super. Ct.), California Superior Court Order
- United States v. Cobb (4th Circuit), ACLU Amicus Brief
- United States v. Cobb (4th Circuit), Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion
- United States v. Ganias (2d Cir.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- Ganias I (2d Cir.), Second Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion
- Ganias II (2d Cir.), Second Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion En Banc
- Commonwealth v. Snow (Mass.), ACLU of Massachusetts Amicus Brief
- Commonwealth v. Snow (Mass.), Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Opinion
- United States v. Morton (5th Cir.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- United States v. Morton (5th Cir.), Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Panel Opinion
- United States v. Basey (9th Cir.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- United States v. Basey (9th Cir.), Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion
- State v. Turay (Or.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. Turay (Or.), Oregon Supreme Court Opinion
- State v. Mefford (Mont.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. Mefford (Mont.), Supreme Court of Montana Opinion
- Facebook, Inc. v. State (N.J.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- Facebook v. State (N.J.), New Jersey Supreme Court Opinion
- State v. Missak (N.J. Super. Ct. App.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. Missak (N.J. Super. Ct. App.), Opinion of the New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division
- United States v. Holcomb (W.D. Wash.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- United States v. Holcomb (9th Cir.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. McDonnell (Md.), ACLU Amicus Brief
- State v. McDonnell (Md.), Maryland Supreme Court Opinion
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Hughes (Mich.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Hughes (Mich.), Michigan Supreme Court OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsPeople v. McCavitt (Ill.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsPeople v. McCavitt (Ill.), Illinois Supreme Court OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Burch (Wisc.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Burch (Wisc.), Wisconsin Supreme Court OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsIn re Search Warrant to Google (Cal. Super. Ct.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsIn re Search Warrant to Google (Cal. Super. Ct.), California Superior Court OrderThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Cobb (4th Circuit), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Cobb (4th Circuit), Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Ganias (2d Cir.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsGanias I (2d Cir.), Second Circuit Court of Appeals OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsGanias II (2d Cir.), Second Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion En BancThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsCommonwealth v. Snow (Mass.), ACLU of Massachusetts Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsCommonwealth v. Snow (Mass.), Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Morton (5th Cir.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Morton (5th Cir.), Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Panel OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Basey (9th Cir.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Basey (9th Cir.), Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Turay (Or.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Turay (Or.), Oregon Supreme Court OpinionDate Filed: 06/15/2023
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Mefford (Mont.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Mefford (Mont.), Supreme Court of Montana OpinionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsFacebook, Inc. v. State (N.J.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsFacebook v. State (N.J.), New Jersey Supreme Court OpinionDate Filed: 06/29/2023
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Missak (N.J. Super. Ct. App.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. Missak (N.J. Super. Ct. App.), Opinion of the New Jersey Superior Court Appellate DivisionThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Holcomb (W.D. Wash.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsUnited States v. Holcomb (9th Cir.), ACLU Amicus BriefDate Filed: 11/20/2023
The Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. McDonnell (Md.), ACLU Amicus BriefThe Warrant Clause in the Digital AgeLegal DocumentsState v. McDonnell (Md.), Maryland Supreme Court OpinionDate Filed: 07/07/2023
