吃瓜大本营

In 1851, Sojourner Truth delivered a speech best known as鈥淎in鈥檛 I A Woman?鈥� to a crowded audience at the Women鈥檚 Convention in Akron, Ohio. At the time, slavery remained in full force, a vibrant enterprise that fueled the American economy. Various laws protected that system, including the Fugitive Slave Act, which resulted in the abduction of 鈥渇ree鈥� Black children, women, and men as well as those who had miraculously escaped to northern cities like Boston or Philadelphia. Bounty hunters then sold their prey to Southern plantation owners. The law denied basic protections for Black people caught in the greed-filled grasps of slavery.
 
Ms. Truth condemned this disgraceful enterprise, which thrived off not only uncompensated labor, but also physical and psychological terror. Most will remember Ms. Truth鈥檚 oration for its vivid descriptions regarding physical labor; Black women were forced to plough, plant, herd, and build 鈥� just as men. Yet far too little attention centers on her condemnation of that system, which made sexual chattel of Black women, and then cruelly sold off Black children. This was human trafficking in the American form, and it lasted for centuries. Ms. Truth :
 
鈥淚 have borne 13 children, and seen most all sold off to slavery, and when I cried out with my mother鈥檚 grief, none but Jesus heard me! And ain鈥檛 I a woman?鈥�
 
Following the Supreme Court鈥檚 decision in June Medical Services v. Russo this week, it is worth reflecting on the racist origins of the anti-abortion movement in the United States, which date back to the ideologies of slavery. Just like slavery, anti-abortion efforts are rooted in white supremacy, the exploitation of Black women, and placing women鈥檚 bodies in service to men. Just like slavery, maximizing wealth and consolidating power motivated the anti-abortion enterprise. Then, just as now, anti-abortion efforts have nothing to do with saving women鈥檚 lives or protecting the interests of children. Today, a person is 14 times more likely to die by carrying a pregnancy to term than by having an abortion, and medical evidence has shown for decades that an abortion is as safe as a penicillin shot鈥攁nd yet abortion remains heavily restricted in states across the country.
 
Prior to the Civil War, abortion and contraceptives were legal in the U.S., used by Indigenous women as well as those who sailed to these lands from Europe. For the most part, the persons who performed all manner of reproductive health care were women 鈥� female midwives. Midwifery was interracial; half of the women who provided reproductive health care were Black women. Other midwives were Indigenous and white.
 
However, in the wake of slavery鈥檚 end, skilled Black midwives represented both real competition for white men who sought to enter the practice of child delivery, and a threat to how obstetricians viewed themselves. Male gynecologists claimed midwifery was a degrading means of obstetrical care. They viewed themselves as elite members of a trained profession with tools such as forceps and other technologies, and the modern convenience of hospitals, which excluded Black and Indigenous women from practice within their institutions.

History would later reveal that it was literally on the backs of Black women鈥檚 bodies that such tools were developed. Dr. Marion Sims famously wrote about his insomniac-induced 鈥渆piphanies鈥� that stirred him to experiment on enslaved Black women, lacerating, suturing, and cutting, providing no anesthesia or pain relief. Only recently have the terrors that Black women endured through nonconsensual experimentation by gynecologists of the 19th and 20th centuries been acknowledged.
 
Successful racist and misogynistic smear campaigns, cleverly designed for political persuasion and to achieve legal reform, described Black midwives as unhygienic, barbarous, ineffective, non-scientific, dangerous, and unprofessional. Dr. Joseph DeLee, a preeminent 20th century obstetrician and fervent opponent to midwifery, stated in a much-quoted 1915 speech, 鈥淧rogress Toward Ideal Obstetrics鈥�:

The midwife is a relic of barbarism. In civilized countries the midwife is wrong, has always been wrong 鈥� The midwife has been a drag on the progress of the science and art of obstetrics. Her existence stunts the one and degrades the other. For many centuries she perverted obstetrics from obtaining any standing at all among the science of medicine 鈥� Even after midwifery was practiced by some of the most brilliant men in the profession, such practice was held opprobrious and degraded.

At the root of these stereotypes were explicit efforts to destroy midwifery and promote white supremacy. As the surge of lynchings, 鈥渟eparate but equal鈥� laws, police violence, and the decimation of successful Black communities during Jim Crow revealed, Black Americans post slavery suffered greatly due to white supremacy, as did Chinese and Japanese workers and their families. Indeed, the racist campaigns launched by doctors against Black midwives extended to anti-immigration legislative platforms targeted at Chinese and Japanese workers. The Page Act, which restricted Chinese women from entering the United States, is a part of this shameful legacy. This broader 20th century anti-Chinese campaign became known as 鈥測ellow peril.鈥� DeLee and Horatio Storer urged white women to 鈥渟pread their loins鈥� across the nation,  a dog whistle about the threat of too many Blacks and Asians in the U.S. 
 
Gynecologists explicitly revealed their motivations in undermining midwifery: They desired financial gains, recognition, and a monopoly. As Dr. DeLee wrote in a 1916 article published in the American Journal of Obstetrics & Disease of Women & Children, 鈥淭here is high art in obstetrics and that it must pay as well for it as for surgery. I will not admit that this is a sordid impulse. It is only common justice to labor, self-sacrifice, and skill.鈥� They believed that men should be paid, but not women 鈥� particularly not Black women.
 
To better understand racial injustice in the anti-abortion movement, remember that American hospitals barred the admission of African Americans both in terms of practice and as patients. And, the American Medical Association (AMA) barred women and Black people from membership. The AMA, founded in 1847, refused to admit Black doctors, informing them, 鈥淵ou come from groups and schools that admit women and that admit irregular practitioners." For this reason, Black doctors formed the National Medical Association in 1895.
 
In 2008, the organization issued a public apology for its active campaigns to close Black medical schools, deny Blacks membership, and other efforts to marginalize Black patients and practitioners. 
 
Gynecologists pushed women out of the field of reproductive health by lobbying state legislatures to ban midwifery and prohibit abortions. Doing so not only undercut women鈥檚 reproductive health, but also drove qualified Black women out of medical services. For these groups, there was no meaningful path to the formalized skill set DeLee claimed necessary.
 
Abortion was an expedient way to frame their campaign to create monopolies on women鈥檚 bodies for male doctors. The American Medical Association explicitly contributed to this cause through its exclusion of women and Black people.
 
Today, as people debate whether anti-abortion platforms benefit Black women, the clear answer is no. The U.S. the developed world in maternal and infant mortality. The U.S. around 50th in the world for maternal safety. Nationally, for Black women, the maternal death rate is four times that of white women, and 10 to 17 times worse in some states.
 
In the wake of both Whole Woman鈥檚 Health and June Medical Services v. Russo, keep in mind that both Texas and Louisiana, where these cases originated, are considered the deadliest in the developed world for a woman to give birth.
 
Sadly, pregnancy has become a death sentence for many in the very places that make reproductive health care access the most fraught and hard to reach. Many of these states (though not all) are former slave states, such as Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Arkansas. As Black people in these states continue to fight for equal access the reproductive care they need, Sojourner Truth鈥檚 1851 speech continues to resonate. And as the Supreme Court demonstrated this week, the fight for justice in reproductive health care and equality in abortion access is far from over. The decision does not advance the equality of poor Black women 鈥� it maintains all other burdensome restrictions already in place. We have much more work to do such that not only DeLee鈥檚 words, but also his racist and exploitative viewpoints, are relegated to history.